Key takeaways
- Two different products share one word. Accumulation math and insurance payout annuities are not the same thing.
- Timing matters. An annuity due is worth one period of interest more than an ordinary annuity.
- Present value is the mirror image. It prices a future payment stream today.
- Payout rates are not returns. Part of each payment is your own principal coming back.
- Fees compound against you. A 1% annual fee can cost six figures over 20 years.
- Guarantees are only as strong as the insurer. Annuities are not FDIC-insured.
The two annuities: accumulation and payout
In finance, an annuity is any series of equal payments made at regular intervals. In insurance, an annuity is a contract that pays income, usually for life. The math in this article covers both: a stream of contributions grows to a future value, and a lump sum can be converted into a stream of withdrawals.
An ordinary annuity pays at the end of each period. An annuity due pays at the beginning. A monthly deposit into a retirement account is usually an ordinary annuity if it is made at month-end, and a rent payment is an annuity due because it is paid at the start of the month.
Future value formula with a worked example
The future value of an ordinary annuity is FV = PMT × ((1 + r)n − 1) ÷ r, where PMT is the payment, r is the rate per period, and n is the number of payments. If the rate is zero, FV = PMT × n.
$500 a month for 10 years at 5% annual interest: r = 0.05 ÷ 12 = 0.0041667 and n = 120. FV = 500 × ((1.0041667)120 − 1) ÷ 0.0041667 = $77,641.14. Contributions are $60,000, so interest is $17,641.14.
The result depends heavily on n. At 20 years the same $500 a month grows to about $205,500, even though contributions only double to $120,000. The extra comes from compounding on a much larger balance.
Timing: ordinary annuity versus annuity due
An annuity due multiplies the ordinary future value by (1 + r), because every payment is made one period earlier and earns one more period of interest. The same $500 stream paid at the beginning of each month is worth 77,641.14 × 1.0041667 = $77,964.64.
The gap equals one period of interest on the ending balance, so it grows with the rate and the size of the balance. At a 7% annual rate, the due version is about 0.58% larger, one month of interest. When comparing quotes, confirm whether the payment is at the beginning or the end of the period; the same dollar amount can mean different totals.
Present value: what a payment stream is worth today
The present value of an ordinary annuity is PV = PMT × (1 − (1 + r)−n) ÷ r. It answers a different question: how much a future stream is worth today at a given discount rate.
$2,000 a month for 20 years at 5%: PV = 2,000 × (1 − 1.0041667−240) ÷ 0.0041667 = $303,050.63. A lump sum of $303,050 today and the $2,000 monthly stream are equivalent at a 5% discount rate.
Present value is the right tool for comparing a pension lump sum with a monthly pension, or a structured settlement with cash today. Use a discount rate that reflects what the money could safely earn, and remember that a higher rate makes the future stream look smaller today.
Payout annuities: converting a lump sum to income
A payout annuity turns savings into income. A simple payout rate of 5% on $500,000 is $25,000 a year, but that payment may include return of principal, so the balance can fall even if the insurer earns the assumed rate. The payout rate is a withdrawal rate, not an investment return.
If the contract amortizes the balance over 20 years at 5%, the payment is $3,299.78 a month, or $39,597 a year, because it returns principal as well as interest. A life-only payout usually pays more than a period-certain payout for the same premium because the insurer pools longevity risk; a joint-and-survivor payout pays less because it must cover two lives.
Payout options: life, period certain, joint and survivor
Life only pays for the annuitant’s lifetime and stops at death, with nothing to heirs. Life with a 10-year or 20-year period certain guarantees payments for at least that long, with the remainder to a beneficiary. Joint and survivor continues payments to a spouse after the first death, often at 100%, 75%, or 50% of the original amount.
Each guarantee lowers the initial payment. A cash refund option returns the unpaid premium to heirs, and an inflation rider increases payments over time but starts lower. The right choice depends on health, marital status, other income, and how much the survivor would need; compare the actual quotes rather than the option labels.
Fees and surrender charges
Annuity fees are usually quoted as annual percentages of account value. A variable annuity might charge 1.25% for mortality and expense risk, 0.15% for administration, 0.60% for underlying funds, and 1.00% for a living-benefit rider, for a total near 3.00% a year. On $100,000 that is about $3,000 a year, before any surrender charge.
Surrender charges apply to early withdrawals, often 7% in year one and declining by one point a year. A $100,000 contract surrendered in year two at 6% costs $6,000. A 1% annual fee on $500,000 over 20 years can reduce the ending balance by roughly $231,000 compared with a 5% gross return and no fee, which is why the fee schedule deserves more attention than the illustrated rate.
Taxes: deferral, withdrawals, and RMDs
Nonqualified annuity growth is tax-deferred. Withdrawals are generally taxed as ordinary income on the gain first, and a 10% additional tax applies to the taxable portion before age 59½, with exceptions. Qualified annuities inside an IRA follow the IRA rules instead; putting a tax-deferred annuity inside an IRA often adds fees without adding deferral.
Required minimum distributions generally begin at age 73, or age 75 for people born in 1960 or later. A 1035 exchange can move an annuity to another contract without current tax, but it does not erase surrender charges or improve a bad contract. Keep the basis records: the taxable portion of each withdrawal depends on the investment in the contract.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the accumulation value with the surrender value and assuming the difference is a loss.
- Using an annual rate as the monthly rate instead of dividing by 12.
- Mixing ordinary and annuity-due timing in one comparison.
- Buying a variable annuity inside an IRA and paying twice for tax deferral.
- Treating an illustrated rate as a guaranteed return.
- Ignoring the surrender period and the 10% early-withdrawal tax.
Caveats: guarantees, insurer risk, and inflation
Annuity guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the insurer. Annuities are not FDIC-insured, and state guaranty associations provide only limited protection if an insurer fails. Check the insurer’s financial strength rating and the coverage limits in your state before committing a large sum.
A fixed payout loses purchasing power. At 3% inflation, a $25,000 annual payment is worth about $18,602 in today’s dollars after 10 years. An inflation rider reduces the starting payment but preserves more of the real income. Finally, annuities are long-term contracts: money needed within a few years belongs in a liquid account, not behind a surrender charge.
Frequently asked questions
What is the future value of an annuity?
The value of a series of equal payments at a future date, including interest. For an ordinary annuity, FV = PMT × ((1 + r)n − 1) ÷ r.
What is the difference between an ordinary annuity and an annuity due?
An ordinary annuity pays at the end of each period; an annuity due pays at the beginning. The due version is worth (1 + r) times more.
How is a payout annuity different from an accumulation annuity?
An accumulation annuity builds value; a payout annuity converts a lump sum into income, often for life, and may return principal with each payment.
Are annuity fees worth it?
Only if the guarantees or tax deferral are worth more than the cost. Compare the total annual fee with a low-cost alternative before deciding.
Are annuities FDIC-insured?
No. They are insurance contracts backed by the insurer, with limited state guaranty association protection.
When can I withdraw from an annuity without the 10% tax?
Generally after age 59½, or under an exception such as death, disability, or a qualifying annuity payment. Ordinary income tax still applies to gains.
Further reading