What this calculator does
Leasing and buying are different ways to pay for the same depreciation. A lease bundles depreciation, rent, and fees into a monthly payment and returns the car at the end. A purchase finances the whole price, builds equity, and leaves you with an asset that may be worth more or less than the remaining loan. Comparing the monthly payments alone is misleading because the lease payment ends with no car and the loan payment ends with a resale value. This calculator puts both on the same timeline: it adds the down payment, the payments actually made, and any remaining loan balance, then subtracts the resale value. The lease side adds the amount due at signing and every lease payment in the period.
How to use it
- Enter the negotiated vehicle price and the down payment you would make to buy.
- Set the loan rate and term; the calculator computes the amortized payment.
- Enter a realistic resale value for the end of the comparison period.
- Enter the lease payment and the amount due at signing from the actual offer.
- Compare the net cost of each option over the same number of years.
How it works
Example calculations
Example 1: $38,000 car, 6.5% for five years, $20,000 resale
The $35,000 loan pays $684.82 per month. Buying nets $24,088.91 after the down payment, 60 payments, and the $20,000 resale value. The lease costs $30,000.00 including $3,000.00 at signing. Buying is cheaper by $5,911.09 in this comparison.
Example 2: $30,000 car, four-year lease at $380
With $2,000 down, a 5.9% five-year loan, and a $15,000 resale value, the buy side nets $19,198.61. The lease totals $20,740.00 over four years. Because the loan still has a balance after four years, the remaining balance is included in the buy cost rather than ignored.
Example 3: $50,000 car, six-year lease at $650
A $8,000 down payment and 7% six-year loan produce a $716.06 payment. Buying nets $34,556.20 after a $25,000 resale value. The lease totals $51,800.00. A high lease payment with a large amount due at signing can make leasing more expensive even when the monthly figure looks close.
What the result means
The difference usually comes from depreciation, the lease's rent charge, and the resale assumption. Buying is not automatically cheaper: a car with steep depreciation and a short ownership period can cost more than a lease, while a reliable car kept for many years usually favors buying. The comparison also ignores the opportunity cost of the down payment and the risk of resale. If you need flexibility, a lease can be worth a premium; if you keep cars for a decade, the buy case gets stronger. The Federal Reserve's leasing guide is a useful check on mileage limits, wear charges, and end-of-lease fees.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the lease payment with the loan payment instead of total net cost.
- Leaving the amount due at signing out of the lease total.
- Using an optimistic resale value that the market will not pay.
- Ignoring excess mileage, wear, and disposition fees at lease end.
- Forgetting that insurance and registration can differ between a leased and owned car.
Assumptions and limits
- The lease payment stays constant for the whole comparison period.
- The resale value is achieved at the end of the period with no selling costs.
- Taxes, registration, insurance, maintenance, and mileage charges are excluded.
- The loan is not prepaid and the rate is fixed.
- The same vehicle and usage are compared on both sides.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the buy cost include the remaining loan balance?
At the end of the period you still owe that balance. If you sell the car, you must pay it off, so it belongs in the net cost. Leaving it out makes buying look cheaper than it is.
Is leasing better for a business?
Sometimes, because lease payments may be deductible and the vehicle does not tie up capital. Tax treatment varies by entity and jurisdiction; ask an accountant. This calculator compares cash cost only.
What mileage should I assume?
Use your real annual mileage. Most leases include 10,000–15,000 miles per year; excess miles are charged at the end. If you routinely exceed the allowance, a lease becomes more expensive.
How do I estimate resale value?
Use a reputable valuation guide or completed listings for the same model, year, mileage, and condition. Subtract anything you would spend to sell it. A residual assumption that is too high can flip the answer.
Does a larger down payment help?
It lowers the loan payment and total interest, but it also increases the cash at risk. For a lease, a large cap reduction is usually a bad idea because you lose that money if the car is totaled.
What is not included in the comparison?
Insurance, maintenance, repairs, registration, taxes, lease acquisition and disposition fees, excess mileage, and wear charges. Add those for your own situation before deciding.
Sources
2026 update
How to use the professional output
This page is not just a formula box. The result is designed to be checked, compared, and taken away.
- Professional worksheet. The result includes the inputs used, the method and scope, and a one-variable sensitivity check for finance calculators.
- A/B scenarios. Save two input sets in the browser and compare the primary, secondary, and breakdown figures side by side.
- Print / PDF and CSV. Print a branded worksheet, or export the year-by-year table when the calculator produces one.
- Quote differences. The section below explains why a bank, lender, broker, or provider can quote a different number.
The formulas and assumptions above still govern the number. The worksheet makes the estimate auditable; it does not make it a lender quote, tax return, or personalized advice.
Before you use a quote
Why your bank, lender, or provider’s number may differ
A lender’s quote can differ from this estimate because the advertised rate is not always the APR, and fees and credit pricing are lender-specific.
What changes the quote
- APR versus interest rate. Origination, documentation, and registration fees are part of the APR but not the note rate.
- Credit and term. A longer term lowers the payment but usually raises total interest.
- Taxes and insurance. Sales tax, registration, and required coverage vary by state and lender.
- Promotional pricing. Dealer or issuer incentives may be conditional and can change the effective cost.
How to compare offers
- Compare the APR and total cost, not only the monthly payment.
- Ask for a written quote or Loan Estimate with all fees itemized.
- Use the same loan amount, term, date, and assumptions for every offer.
- Check what is excluded: taxes, insurance, closing costs, maintenance, or provider fees.
- Keep an emergency reserve; the lowest payment is not always the safest choice.
Reference: CFPB Loan Estimate explainer.