Key takeaways
- The term resets. A new 30-year loan can lower the payment by stretching the balance.
- Break-even is the first test. Closing costs divided by monthly savings shows how long recovery takes.
- Compare the remaining term. Refinancing from year 10 to a new 30-year loan adds 20 years.
- Cash-out is a new loan, not free equity. It raises the balance and the risk.
- Stay long enough to break even. If you may move soon, the refinance can lose money.
Why the payment falls
A refinance replaces the old loan with a new one. If the new rate is lower, the interest portion falls. If the term is also longer, the principal is spread over more months, so the payment falls further. The lower payment is real, but the total interest can rise because the balance is carried longer.
Break-even
Break-even is the number of months needed for the monthly savings to recover the closing costs. If the refinance costs $4,500 and saves $150 a month, the break-even is 30 months. If you sell or refinance again before that, you may not recover the cost. The calculator should show both the break-even and the lifetime interest.
An example
A $300,000 balance at 7% with 25 years left has a certain payment. Refinancing to 6% over 30 years lowers the payment, but it adds five years. The monthly savings may look attractive; the total interest may be higher. A 20-year or 25-year new loan can preserve the payoff date and still lower the rate.
Cash-out refinance
A cash-out refinance increases the loan balance and gives the difference in cash. It can consolidate debt or fund a renovation, but it turns unsecured debt into secured debt and raises the LTV. Compare the new rate, closing costs, and the risk of a higher payment before using home equity.
What to compare
- New rate and APR
- Monthly payment and break-even month
- Remaining term versus new term
- Closing costs and fees
- Total interest over the expected holding period
- Cash-out amount and new LTV
No-cost refinance does not mean free
A “no-cost” refinance may have a higher rate or the costs rolled into the balance. Compare the rate, APR, closing costs, and total interest. A lender credit can cover the fees, but it is usually paid for through a higher rate.
When the break-even is short
If the break-even is short and you plan to stay, the refinance can make sense even if the term resets. If the break-even is longer than your expected stay, the savings may not materialize. The break-even is a useful filter, not the only test.
Keep the payoff date
Ask for a new loan with the same remaining term or a shorter one. A 20-year loan can lower the rate without adding years. Compare the payment, total interest, and the date the loan is actually paid off.
Closing costs to expect
Refinance closing costs can include an application fee, origination fee, appraisal, title search and insurance, recording fees, and prepaid interest. The Loan Estimate lists the costs; compare the total, not only the rate. Some costs are fixed and some depend on the loan amount or location.
Should you refinance for a small rate cut?
A small rate cut may not recover the closing costs before you sell. Run the break-even and compare the monthly savings with the cost. If the break-even is longer than your expected stay, the refinance is harder to justify.
Keep the old documents
Compare the new Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure with the old note. Check the balance, term, rate, and whether the old loan has a prepayment penalty.
Ask the lender for the break-even in writing and compare it with your expected stay.
A refinance is a new loan; read the note before signing.
Compare the new loan with the old note line by line.
Compare the new payment, break-even, and payoff date before committing.
A $300,000 loan at 7% with 25 years remaining. Refinance to 6% over 30 years: the payment falls, but the term extends. If closing costs are $6,000 and the monthly saving is $214, the break-even is about 28 months. If you stay five years, the refinance may pay off.
Term reset
A new 30-year loan restarts the amortization clock. The lower payment comes partly from spreading the balance over more years. A 20-year or 25-year new loan can preserve the payoff date and still lower the rate. Compare the total interest, not only the payment.
Cash-out
A cash-out refinance increases the balance. It can consolidate debt or fund a renovation, but it turns unsecured debt into secured debt. Compare the new LTV, rate, and total cost. Do not use the home as a credit card without a repayment plan.
What to compare
Compare the rate, APR, closing costs, break-even, new term, and total interest over the expected holding period. A lower payment is not the same as a lower cost.
Ask the lender for the break-even in writing.
Check the break-even.
Review the break-even.
Now check.
Now.
Frequently asked questions
Is a lower payment always better?
No. A longer term can lower the payment and raise total interest. Compare the break-even and the payoff date.
Should I refinance if I plan to move soon?
Usually not unless the break-even is shorter than your expected stay or the lender offers a no-cost refinance with acceptable terms.
Is a cash-out refinance a good way to pay off cards?
It can lower the rate, but it secures the debt against your home and raises the balance. Compare the risk and the total cost.
Further reading
Keep exploring
Decision path