Key takeaways
- Total return is not annualized return.
- Time horizon matters.
- Dividends and interest count.
- Contributions change the calculation.
- Compare like with like.
Total return
If you invest $10,000, receive $500 in dividends, and end with $11,500, the total return is ($11,500 − $10,000 + $500) ÷ $10,000 = 20%. If the holding period is three years, the annualized return is (1.20)^(1/3) − 1 = 6.27%.
CAGR
CAGR = (ending value ÷ beginning value)^(1/years) − 1. It measures the compound annual growth rate of a single lump sum. It does not account for contributions or withdrawals; use a money-weighted return for those.
An example
An investment grows from $5,000 to $8,000 over five years with no dividends. Total return 60%; CAGR = (1.60)^(1/5) − 1 = 9.86%. A 60% return over two years is 26.5% annualized. The same total return over different periods is not comparable without annualizing.
Contributions
If you add money along the way, the simple return can mislead. A contribution before a gain gets credit for the gain; a contribution after does not. Use a time-weighted or money-weighted return for a portfolio with cash flows.
What to compare
Compare total return, annualized return, risk, and fees. A high total return over a long period can be a modest annualized return. A short-term high return may not repeat.
Total return example
Buy at $10,000, receive $500 in dividends, sell at $12,000. Total return = ($12,000 − $10,000 + $500) ÷ $10,000 = 25%. Over four years, annualized = (1.25)^(1/4) − 1 = 5.74%. The 25% total return is not a 25% annual return.
Money-weighted return
If you add money during the period, the simple return can mislead. A contribution before a gain gets credit for the gain; after does not. Use a money-weighted return (IRR) or time-weighted return for a portfolio with cash flows.
What to compare
Compare total return, annualized return, risk, and fees. A high total return over a long period can be modest per year.
Annualizing a loss
An investment falls from $10,000 to $7,000 over three years. Total return is −30%. Annualized = (0.70)^(1/3) − 1 = −11.2%. A loss is not linear: recovering from −30% requires a 42.9% gain. Annualizing shows the per-year rate, not the recovery needed.
Comparing funds
Compare total return, annualized return, expense ratio, and risk. A fund with a higher annualized return but much higher volatility may not be better. Use at least three to five years, and compare the same period.
What to compare
Compare the annualized return, the risk, the fees, and the tax treatment. A single year is not a track record.
Contribution example
Invest $10,000 at the start, add $5,000 at the end of year one, end with $18,000 after two years. Total gain is $3,000 on $15,000 contributed, but the timing matters. A money-weighted return (IRR) accounts for when the cash was invested; a simple return does not.
What to compare
Compare the annualized return, the cash-flow timing, and the risk. A simple return can overstate or understate the experience.
Risk-adjusted return
A 10% return with high volatility is not necessarily better than a 7% return with low volatility. Compare the return with the risk taken. The Sharpe ratio measures excess return per unit of volatility, but it has its own assumptions.
What to compare
Compare the annualized return, the volatility, the fees, and the tax treatment. A single return number is not enough.
Benchmark comparison
Compare the investment with a relevant benchmark over the same period, not a generic index. A small-cap fund should be compared with a small-cap benchmark, not the S&P 500. The benchmark should match the risk and style.
What to compare
Compare the return, risk, fees, and benchmark. A single year is not a track record.
Final check
Compare the annualized return, risk, fees, and benchmark. A single year is not a track record.
Final check
Compare the annualized return, risk, fees, and benchmark. A single year is not a track record, and a total return without the holding period is incomplete.
Final check
Compare the annualized return, risk, fees, and benchmark. A single year is not a track record, and a total return without the holding period is incomplete.
Use the same period and a relevant benchmark.
Compare the annualized return, risk, fees, and benchmark over the same period. A single year is not a track record, and a total return without the holding period is incomplete.
Compare the annualized return, risk, fees, and benchmark over the same period. A single year is not a track record, and a total return without the holding period is incomplete.
Use a relevant benchmark.
Compare the annualized return, risk, fees, and benchmark over the same period. A single year is not a track record, and a total return without the holding period is incomplete.
Use a relevant benchmark and a multi-year window.
Check the annualized return against a relevant benchmark over a multi-year period, and include fees and risk.
Now check a multi-year window and a relevant benchmark.
Compare a multi-year window with a relevant benchmark, and include fees and risk.
Now compare a multi-year window with a relevant benchmark, and include fees and risk in the decision.
Compare the annualized return with the holding period before judging the result.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between total and annualized return?
Total return is the cumulative gain; annualized return is the equivalent per-year rate.
Does CAGR include dividends?
CAGR uses the ending value; if dividends are reinvested, they are included in that value.
How do contributions affect return?
They change the money-weighted return. Use a cash-flow-aware calculation for a portfolio.
Why annualize?
To compare investments with different holding periods on a common basis.
Further reading