Key takeaways
- Gross is not net. Taxes, benefits, and retirement contributions come out first.
- FICA is separate. Social Security and Medicare are payroll taxes, not income tax.
- Withholding is not liability. Your tax return reconciles the two.
- Pre-tax deductions reduce taxable pay. They can lower income tax while still affecting take-home pay.
- Employer cost is higher than gross pay. Employer FICA and benefits are real costs.
Start with gross pay and pay frequency
Gross pay is the amount before taxes and deductions. The same annual salary produces different paycheck amounts depending on frequency: weekly has 52 periods, biweekly 26, semi-monthly 24, monthly 12. A biweekly paycheck is not simply a monthly paycheck divided by two; there are two extra pay periods in most years.
For a professional estimate, keep the pay period and the annual view separate. The per-paycheck number is what hits the bank; the annual number is what matters for tax and benefits planning.
Pre-tax deductions
Pre-tax deductions can include a traditional 401(k), health insurance premiums, an HSA, or dependent-care accounts. They reduce taxable wages for income tax, but not every deduction reduces FICA. That is why two paychecks with the same gross pay can have different Social Security and Medicare amounts.
The calculator shows pre-tax deductions separately so you can see the effect on taxable pay, net pay, and the annual total.
Federal, state, and local withholding
Federal withholding depends on your W-4, filing status, other income, and credits. State rules vary widely; some states have no income tax, some use flat rates, and some use brackets. Local tax may be a city or county tax. The calculator asks for combined rates because it is not a jurisdiction-specific withholding engine.
Use the result as a planning estimate, then check your pay stub and the official withholding tables for the exact amount.
FICA
FICA includes Social Security and Medicare. The employee share is commonly shown as 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare, or 7.65% combined. The Social Security wage base and the Additional Medicare Tax can change the effective amount at higher incomes; the calculator does not model those caps unless you adjust the rate.
The employer also pays a share. That employer cost is part of total compensation but does not appear in your net pay.
A worked example
Suppose gross pay is $2,000 biweekly, pre-tax deductions are $150, federal withholding is 12%, state withholding is 5%, local tax is 0%, FICA is 7.65%, and other deductions are $100. Taxable pay is $1,850. Federal tax is $222, state tax is $92.50, FICA is $141.53, and net pay is about $1,294. The annual view multiplies each line by 26 and shows the employer cost separately.
These rates are illustrative, not a tax table. Your actual withholding depends on your W-4 and payroll system.
Why your paycheck may differ
Overtime, bonuses, commissions, shift differentials, benefit changes, garnishments, and mid-year raises all change the calculation. A payroll system may use cumulative withholding, supplemental wage rules, or a different state formula. The calculator’s flat rates are a simplification.
What to do with the result
Use net pay for cash-flow planning and annual net for savings goals. Use the employer cost view when comparing job offers, because a higher gross salary can be offset by expensive benefits or a smaller retirement match. Do not use the estimate to file a tax return; use it to ask better questions.
Check the annual view before changing a deduction
A deduction that looks small on one paycheck can be large over a year. Compare the per-paycheck and annual columns before increasing a 401(k) or HSA contribution. Check the employer match and vesting schedule too; the match is part of total compensation and can change the effective value of the deduction.
What comes out of a paycheck
Federal income tax, state and local income tax, Social Security (6.2%), Medicare (1.45%), and any pre-tax or post-tax deductions. The employer withholds based on the W-4 and payroll tables; the actual liability is settled on the annual return. A refund means too much was withheld; a balance due means too little.
Pre-tax deductions
Traditional 401(k) contributions, health insurance premiums, and some HSA contributions reduce taxable wages. Roth contributions do not reduce taxable wages. The order of deductions matters for the final net pay.
State and local
State withholding depends on the state form and the employee’s residence and work location. Local tax may apply in some cities and counties. A federal-only estimate will overstate net pay for most employees.
What to compare
Compare gross pay, taxable wages, withholding, deductions, and net pay. The W-4 and the state form control the estimate; the annual return controls the final liability.
Compare the first pay stub with the annual estimate after any W-4 change.
Then check the state withholding.
Check state withholding.
Now check.
Check the state withholding.
Frequently asked questions
Does this use real federal or state tax tables?
No. It uses the combined rates you enter. For exact withholding, use the official IRS and state tables or your payroll provider.
What is FICA?
FICA is Social Security and Medicare payroll tax. The employee share is separate from federal income tax withholding.
Why is my net pay lower than the calculator?
Your payroll may include additional deductions, a different withholding rate, local tax, garnishments, or benefit contributions that are not in the model.
Should I include employer benefits in my salary comparison?
Yes. Employer FICA, health contributions, retirement match, and other benefits are part of total compensation, even though they are not take-home pay.
Further reading
Keep exploring
Decision path