The short answer: compare mortgages on three layers: the monthly payment, the cash due at closing, and the total cost over the time you will actually keep the loan. A $320,000 30-year loan at 6.75% costs $2,075.51 a month and $427,185 in interest. The same loan at 6.25% with 1.5 points costs $1,970.30 and $389,306, but you pay $4,800 upfront; the $105.22 monthly saving takes about 46 months to repay the points. APR folds most closing costs into one rate, but it assumes you keep the loan to maturity.

Key takeaways

  • Payment is not cost. A lower payment can carry more total interest.
  • Points are prepaid interest. One point is 1% of the loan amount.
  • Break-even = points ÷ monthly savings. Hold shorter and the points lose.
  • Lender credits reverse the trade. A higher rate buys cash at closing.
  • APR is a full-term average. It is useful for comparing, not for predicting your cost.
  • Compare Loan Estimates on the same date and terms. Otherwise the numbers are not comparable.

The payment formula and what it leaves out

For a fixed-rate mortgage, the monthly principal-and-interest payment is M = P × r(1 + r)n ÷ ((1 + r)n − 1). P is the loan amount, r is the annual rate divided by 12, and n is the number of monthly payments: 360 for 30 years, 180 for 15. Total interest is M × n − P.

The formula covers principal and interest only. It leaves out property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, HOA dues, and closing costs. Two offers with the same rate can still have different total monthly payments if their escrow estimates differ, so compare principal and interest first and the full payment second.

Worked example: two 30-year offers

Loan A: $320,000 at 6.75% for 30 years. r = 0.005625 and n = 360, so the payment is $2,075.51 and total interest is $427,185.

Loan B: $320,000 at 6.25% for 30 years with 1.5 discount points. The payment is $1,970.30 and total interest is $389,306, a saving of $105.22 a month and $37,879 over the full term. The points cost 1.5% × 320,000 = $4,800 at closing.

Divide the points by the monthly saving: 4,800 ÷ 105.22 = 45.6 months. If you keep the loan longer than about 3.8 years, B wins on interest; sell or refinance sooner and the $4,800 has not been recovered.

Points and break-even

A discount point is a fee paid at closing to lower the interest rate. One point equals 1% of the loan amount, so one point on $320,000 is $3,200. Lenders may offer fractions, and the rate reduction per point varies with the market and the loan.

The break-even in months is points cost ÷ monthly payment saving. Compare that with how long you expect to keep the loan. A common mistake is to count the full 30-year interest saving while planning to move in five years; over five years, B’s interest advantage is much smaller than $37,879 and may not cover $4,800.

Points can be tax-deductible in some circumstances, but the rules differ for a purchase and a refinance. Ask a tax adviser before treating a deduction as part of the break-even arithmetic.

Lender credits: the reverse of points

A lender credit is cash toward closing costs in exchange for a higher rate. On the same $320,000 loan, 6.50% with a $2,600 credit costs $2,022.62 a month, which is $52.32 more than the 6.25% offer. The credit covers 2,600 ÷ 52.32 = 49.7 months of the higher payment.

A credit makes sense when cash at closing is the binding constraint or when you expect to sell or refinance before the break-even. It costs more over a long hold. The mistake is to compare the credit offer’s rate with the no-credit rate and conclude the credit is free; it is a loan in the form of a higher rate.

APR: what it includes and what it misses

The annual percentage rate is an annualized measure of the finance charge under Regulation Z. It includes the interest rate, discount points, broker fees, and most closing costs, which is why it can differ from the note rate. Loan B’s 6.25% note rate with 1.5 points has an APR of about 6.39%; Loan A’s 6.75% with no points has an APR near 6.75%.

APR assumes the loan is held to maturity and that the borrower makes every payment on schedule. It does not know your holding period, and it excludes some costs, such as optional services and certain fees. A lower APR is generally the cheaper loan over the full term, but the difference can be small and the cash at closing can matter more.

Term length: 15 years versus 30

A $320,000 loan at 5.75% for 15 years costs $2,657.31 a month and $158,316 in total interest. The 30-year Loan A costs $581.80 less each month but $268,869 more in interest. The shorter term builds equity faster and costs far less, but it requires the higher payment to be sustainable through a job loss or a large expense.

Do not compare the 15-year payment with the 30-year payment alone. Compare the payment with your budget, the interest saved, and the opportunity cost of the extra cash. If the difference is invested at a higher after-tax return, the 30-year loan can still be the better financial choice.

Total cost over your holding period

Total cost = principal + interest + points + lender fees + third-party closing costs. Over a 10-year hold, Loan A pays about $202,025 of interest; Loan B pays about $185,996 plus $4,800 of points, or $190,796. B saves roughly $11,229 over 10 years, far less than the full-term figure but still positive.

Run the same arithmetic for your expected holding period and add the cost of selling. A refinance or move resets the break-even, and a low rate with high upfront costs can be the most expensive choice for a short hold.

Reading Loan Estimates side by side

The Loan Estimate is a three-page disclosure. Page 1 shows the loan terms and projected payments, page 2 itemizes closing costs, and page 3 shows comparisons including APR and total interest percentage. Request estimates from several lenders on the same day, for the same loan amount, term, and rate-lock period.

Check the loan amount, interest rate, monthly principal and interest, estimated escrow, estimated taxes and insurance, points, lender credits, and the “Services You Can Shop For” section. A lower APR on a different loan amount or term is not a better offer; it is a different loan.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing principal and interest only while ignoring taxes, insurance, PMI, and HOA dues.
  • Counting the full-term interest saving on a loan you will keep for five years.
  • Ignoring discount points and lender credits when comparing rates.
  • Comparing APRs on different loan amounts, terms, or lock periods.
  • Assuming a lower rate always wins, even when the upfront cost never breaks even.
  • Forgetting that an adjustable rate can reset after the fixed period.

Caveats: escrow, PMI, and loan features

This comparison assumes fixed-rate, fully amortizing loans. It does not model adjustable rates, interest-only payments, negative amortization, or balloon terms. If the down payment is below 20%, mortgage insurance adds a monthly cost that can disappear at a specific loan-to-value ratio; ask for the removal terms.

Escrow estimates vary by lender and can change after closing if taxes or insurance rise. Prepayment penalties, if any, belong in the comparison, and a lender credit may carry a recapture clause if you refinance too soon. Read the fine print on page 3 of the Loan Estimate and in the closing documents.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare two mortgage offers fairly?

Use the same loan amount, term, and date; compare payment, cash at closing, APR, and total cost over your expected holding period.

What is a mortgage point?

A fee equal to 1% of the loan amount paid at closing to reduce the rate. One point on a $320,000 loan costs $3,200.

Is a lower APR always better?

Over the full term, usually. For a short hold, upfront costs may not break even, so compare total cost over your holding period.

Should I take a lender credit?

Take it if cash at closing is tight or you will move or refinance before the higher payment repays the credit.

Does APR include closing costs?

It includes most finance charges, such as points, broker fees, and many third-party costs, but not every closing cost.

Is a 15-year loan always cheaper?

It has less total interest, but the higher payment can strain a budget. Compare the payment, the interest saved, and the opportunity cost.

Further reading

Keep exploring

Read next 2027 Federal Tax Brackets and Retirement Limits The IRS 2027 standard deduction, federal brackets, 401(k) and IRA limits, Social Security wage base, and what changed… Read next APR to APY: Compounding and the Real Annual Cost APY = (1 + APR / n)^n - 1. Convert nominal APR to effective APY at any compounding… Read next Present Value: Discounting Future Cash Flows PV = FV / (1 + r / n)^(n x t). Discount a lump sum or a stream…