Skip to content

Finance

Mortgage Comparison Calculator

Enter the amount, rate, and term for two mortgage offers. The calculator estimates the monthly principal-and-interest payment and total interest for each loan, then shows the monthly difference and which loan costs less over its full term. It compares fixed-rate loans only and does not include taxes, insurance, or closing costs.

Updated 2026-11-12 Editorial estimate Calccc Editorial Team Free · No sign-up

Loading calculator…

What this calculator does

Two mortgage offers can look similar at a glance but differ in monthly payment, total interest, and how long you carry the debt. This side-by-side calculator puts both loans on the same basis so the tradeoffs are easier to see. A lower rate usually helps, but a shorter term can raise the payment while cutting total interest. Use the comparison to frame a conversation with a lender, not as a substitute for a Loan Estimate.

How to use it

  1. Enter the loan amount, annual rate, and term in years for Loan A.
  2. Enter the same details for Loan B.
  3. Compare the monthly payments and the total interest for each loan.
  4. Check the monthly difference and the lower-total-interest option.

How it works

Each payment uses M = P x r x (1 + r)^n / ((1 + r)^n - 1). P is the loan amount, r is the annual rate divided by 12 and by 100, and n is the number of monthly payments. Total paid is M x n; total interest is total paid - P. The monthly difference is Loan A's payment minus Loan B's. The cheaper option has the lower total interest when both loans are paid on schedule.

Example calculations

Example 1: $300,000 at 6.5% vs. 6.0%, 30 years

Loan A costs about $1,896.20 a month and $382,633 in total interest. Loan B costs about $1,798.65 a month and $347,515 in interest. Loan B is $97.55 lower monthly and $35,119 cheaper over the full term.

Example 2: $250,000 at 7% for 30 years vs. 6.5% for 15 years

Loan A costs about $1,663.26 a month and $348,772 in interest. Loan B costs about $2,177.77 a month but only $141,998 in interest. Loan B is $514.51 more monthly and $206,774 cheaper overall.

Example 3: $400,000 at 6% for 30 years vs. 5.75% for 20 years

Loan A costs about $2,398.20 a month with $463,353 in interest. Loan B costs about $2,808.33 a month with $274,000 in interest. Loan B is $410.13 more monthly but $189,353 cheaper overall.

What the result means

The monthly payment is a cash-flow number, while total interest is a lifetime cost. A 30-year loan usually wins on payment and loses on total interest; a 15-year loan usually does the reverse. Neither is automatically better. Compare the payment with your budget, the total interest with your time horizon, and the closing costs and fees that this calculator leaves out. A lower rate is valuable, but paying points or fees to get it can erase the savings if you sell or refinance early. Also compare the APR and the official Loan Estimate, which include some costs that a simple rate comparison omits. Choose based on both payment comfort and total cost.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing payments without comparing total interest.
  • Using advertised rates instead of the rates on your Loan Estimates.
  • Ignoring closing costs, points, and lender fees.

Assumptions and limits

  • Both loans are fixed-rate and fully amortizing with equal monthly payments.
  • Payments are made on time and no extra payments are made.
  • Taxes, insurance, HOA dues, and closing costs are excluded.

Frequently asked questions

Which loan is cheaper?

This calculator treats the loan with lower total interest as cheaper. Check the monthly difference too, because that loan may require a higher payment.

Why can a shorter loan cost less overall but more each month?

A shorter term spreads the principal over fewer payments, so each payment is larger. Less time to accrue interest usually means lower total interest.

Does this include taxes and insurance?

No. It covers principal and interest only. Add property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues, and mortgage insurance for a full housing cost.

Can I use this for adjustable-rate mortgages?

No. It assumes a fixed rate for the entire term. An adjustable rate can change, so its payment and total interest are not fixed.

What is the monthly difference?

It is Loan A's payment minus Loan B's. A positive number means Loan B has the lower payment; a negative number means Loan A does.

Should I choose the loan with the lowest payment?

Not automatically. The lowest payment may come with a longer term and much more interest. Match the choice to your budget, plans to move or refinance, and total cost.

Sources

This calculator is an educational estimate only and is not financial advice. It compares principal and interest for fixed-rate loans and does not include taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, HOA dues, points, or closing costs. Rates and fees vary by lender and borrower. Review each Loan Estimate and consider speaking with a licensed mortgage professional.

2026 update

How to use the professional output

This page is not just a formula box. The result is designed to be checked, compared, and taken away.

  • Professional worksheet. The result includes the inputs used, the method and scope, and a one-variable sensitivity check for finance calculators.
  • A/B scenarios. Save two input sets in the browser and compare the primary, secondary, and breakdown figures side by side.
  • Print / PDF and CSV. Print a branded worksheet, or export the year-by-year table when the calculator produces one.
  • Quote differences. The section below explains why a bank, lender, broker, or provider can quote a different number.

The formulas and assumptions above still govern the number. The worksheet makes the estimate auditable; it does not make it a lender quote, tax return, or personalized advice.

Before you use a quote

Why your bank, lender, or provider’s number may differ

A mortgage quote can differ from this estimate even when the loan amount and rate look the same. The lender’s Loan Estimate is the document that controls the actual offer.

What changes the quote

  • Rate versus APR. Points, lender credits, and closing costs can make the APR different from the note rate.
  • Escrow and insurance. Property tax, homeowners insurance, PMI, and HOA are local and lender-specific.
  • Loan-level pricing. Credit score, down payment, occupancy, property type, and loan size can change the rate.
  • Timing. Rates can change daily; a quote is not a lock until it is locked in writing.

How to compare offers

  1. Compare the APR and total cost, not only the monthly payment.
  2. Ask for a written quote or Loan Estimate with all fees itemized.
  3. Use the same loan amount, term, date, and assumptions for every offer.
  4. Check what is excluded: taxes, insurance, closing costs, maintenance, or provider fees.
  5. Keep an emergency reserve; the lowest payment is not always the safest choice.

Reference: CFPB Loan Estimate explainer.

Go deeper

Guides that explain the math

Mortgage Comparison: APR, Points, and Total Cost
Finance

Mortgage Comparison: APR, Points, and Total Cost

Compare mortgage offers by payment, points, APR, and total cost over the years you will actually keep the loan.

8 min read

Calccc Editorial Team · Updated 2026-11-12

Prepared by Calccc Editorial Team as an educational estimate. This page is not a licensed professional review and is not financial, medical, legal, or tax advice.

Editorial estimate prepared by the Calccc Editorial Team; not a licensed professional review.