What this calculator does
Debt consolidation replaces several balances with one loan. The pitch is usually a lower rate and one payment, but the useful question is narrower: does the new loan cost less in total, and does the lower payment come from a lower rate or from stretching the term? This calculator answers both. It amortizes the new loan, simulates the current debts month by month with the payment you actually make, and compares the interest. If the current payment is smaller than the monthly interest, the current debt never pays off, and the comparison has to start there rather than with the advertised consolidation rate.
How to use it
- Add up the balances you would repay with the consolidation loan.
- Enter a weighted average APR for those debts, not the rate on the largest one.
- Enter the total you currently pay each month across all of them.
- Enter the consolidation loan's rate, term, and any fees added to the balance.
- Compare the monthly saving with the lifetime interest difference before deciding.
How it works
Example calculations
Example 1: $25,000 at 22%, consolidated at 11% for five years
The current debts take 52 months to clear at $750 per month and cost $13,990.25 in interest. The new loan pays $543.56 per month for 60 months and costs $7,613.63. That is $206.44 less each month and $6,376.62 less interest over the life of the debt.
Example 2: $15,000 at 24% with a $300 fee rolled in
A $500 payment clears the current balance in about 47 months with $8,136.56 of interest. The 9% loan finances $15,300.00 and pays $317.60 per month; its interest is $3,756.17. Rolling the fee into the loan reduces the apparent rate benefit, so compare the all-in principal, not just the quoted APR.
Example 3: $40,000 at 18%, consolidated at 12% for seven years
The current $1,000 payment takes about 62 months and costs $21,544.90 in interest. The seven-year loan lowers the payment to $706.11 but raises the interest to $19,313.18. The monthly saving is real, but the longer term can erase the rate advantage; check the lifetime line.
What the result means
A consolidation loan is only cheaper when the lower rate outweighs the longer term and the fees. A five-year loan at half the current APR usually wins, but a seven-year loan at a modestly lower rate may cost more in total. The monthly payment comparison is a cash-flow test; the lifetime interest comparison is the wealth test. If you consolidate credit card debt and then run the cards up again, the new loan adds a payment without solving the underlying gap between income and spending. A nonprofit credit counselor can review the whole budget, and the CFPB warns that for-profit debt settlement and repair companies often charge for things you can do yourself.
Common mistakes
- Comparing only the new monthly payment and ignoring the extra years of interest.
- Using the rate on the largest debt instead of a weighted average APR.
- Forgetting origination fees, balance-transfer fees, or a prepayment penalty.
- Assuming a variable-rate consolidation loan will stay at today's rate.
- Consolidating and then reusing the paid-off cards, which doubles the debt.
Assumptions and limits
- All rates are fixed for the life of the comparison.
- The current payment stays the same until the balance is repaid.
- Fees are financed into the new loan balance.
- No extra payments, late fees, or rate changes are modeled.
- The new loan is fully disbursed and replaces the listed debts.
Frequently asked questions
Does consolidation always lower my interest?
No. It lowers interest only when the new APR is low enough to offset fees and any longer term. A longer loan at a slightly lower rate can cost more in total interest even though the monthly payment falls.
What if my current payment is less than the interest?
Then the balance grows and never pays off. The calculator flags that case instead of showing a payoff time. You need a higher payment, a lower rate, or both before consolidation can help.
Should I include a car loan or mortgage?
Usually not. Secured debts already have low rates, and replacing them with unsecured consolidation debt can put the asset at risk if you default. Compare the rates and the collateral separately.
How does a balance transfer compare?
A zero-interest balance transfer can be cheaper than a consolidation loan during the promotional period, but the transfer fee and the post-promotion rate matter. Model the full repayment period, not just the promo months.
Will consolidation hurt my credit score?
A new account and a hard inquiry can lower the score slightly, while lower utilization may help over time. The effect depends on your file. Check your reports and avoid applying to several lenders in a short window.
Is debt consolidation the same as debt settlement?
No. Consolidation borrows money to repay the debts in full. Settlement negotiates to pay less than owed and usually damages credit. The CFPB distinguishes them because the risks and the fees are different.
Sources
2026 update
How to use the professional output
This page is not just a formula box. The result is designed to be checked, compared, and taken away.
- Professional worksheet. The result includes the inputs used, the method and scope, and a one-variable sensitivity check for finance calculators.
- A/B scenarios. Save two input sets in the browser and compare the primary, secondary, and breakdown figures side by side.
- Print / PDF and CSV. Print a branded worksheet, or export the year-by-year table when the calculator produces one.
- Quote differences. The section below explains why a bank, lender, broker, or provider can quote a different number.
The formulas and assumptions above still govern the number. The worksheet makes the estimate auditable; it does not make it a lender quote, tax return, or personalized advice.
Before you use a quote
Why your bank, lender, or provider’s number may differ
A lender’s quote can differ from this estimate because the advertised rate is not always the APR, and fees and credit pricing are lender-specific.
What changes the quote
- APR versus interest rate. Origination, documentation, and registration fees are part of the APR but not the note rate.
- Credit and term. A longer term lowers the payment but usually raises total interest.
- Taxes and insurance. Sales tax, registration, and required coverage vary by state and lender.
- Promotional pricing. Dealer or issuer incentives may be conditional and can change the effective cost.
How to compare offers
- Compare the APR and total cost, not only the monthly payment.
- Ask for a written quote or Loan Estimate with all fees itemized.
- Use the same loan amount, term, date, and assumptions for every offer.
- Check what is excluded: taxes, insurance, closing costs, maintenance, or provider fees.
- Keep an emergency reserve; the lowest payment is not always the safest choice.
Reference: CFPB Loan Estimate explainer.