Key takeaways
- Order matters. Labor and materials, then markup, then discount, then tax.
- Tax applies to the final pre-tax price, never to cost.
- A discount comes out of profit, not out of markup.
- Contingency is for risk, not a hidden margin.
- Written assumptions and exclusions prevent most payment disputes.
What a quote has to do
A quote does three jobs: it states a price, it defines the scope that price covers, and it sets the terms under which the price can change. A number without scope is an invitation to argue about what was included. A scope without a price is not a quote.
Quotes differ from estimates and invoices. An estimate is a best guess that may be revised; a quote is normally fixed for a stated period; an invoice is a demand for payment after or during the work. Mixing the three in one document creates ambiguity about which number is binding.
The build order
Labor = hours × hourly rate | Subtotal = labor + materials
Markup = subtotal × markup % | Price before tax = subtotal + markup
Discount = price before tax × discount % | Tax = (price before tax − discount) × tax %
Quote total = price before tax − discount + tax
The order is not arbitrary. Markup recovers overhead and profit on the work performed, so it applies to labor and materials. A discount reduces the price the customer pays, so it comes after markup. Tax is collected on the amount actually charged, so it comes last.
Worked example
| Line | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Labor | 10 h × $50 = $500 | 5 h × $80 = $400 |
| Materials | $200 | $500 |
| Subtotal | $700 | $900 |
| Markup | 20% = $140 | 10% = $90 |
| Price before tax | $840 | $990 |
| Sales tax | 8% = $67.20 | 6% = $59.40 |
| Quote total | $907.20 | $1,049.40 |
The second quote earns a smaller markup on a larger base: $90 on $900 rather than $140 on $700. Whether that is right depends on the competitive situation and the risk in the job, not on which total is larger.
Read the lines back to the customer in the same order they were built. A quote that shows labor, materials, markup, tax, and total separately can be checked by the customer and audited by you. A single lump sum cannot.
Discounts: where they sit and what they cost
A discount applied after markup comes directly out of profit. Starting from the $840 pre-tax price with $700 of cost, a 10% discount reduces the price to $756. Tax at 8% is $60.48 and the total is $816.48. Gross profit falls from $140 to $56, and the margin falls from 16.7% to 7.4%.
Discounts are not cheaper because they are expressed as a percentage of price rather than cost. At a 20% markup, a 10% discount gives back 60% of the profit. The volume needed to recover it is the original profit divided by the discounted profit, minus one: 140 ÷ 56 − 1 = 150% more work.
Put the discount on its own line with a reason and an approval. A discount buried inside the labor rate is invisible to the customer and to the next person who prices a similar job.
Contingency and risk
Contingency is a priced allowance for known unknowns: weather, access, site conditions, or material price movement. It belongs in the cost base before markup, so the markup also applies to the risk being carried. A 10% contingency on the $700 subtotal adds $70; with 20% markup the pre-tax price is $924, and 8% tax brings the total to $997.92.
Contingency is not profit. If it is not used, it either reduces the final invoice or stays in the price as margin, and the quote should say which. Hiding contingency inside inflated hours is worse: it makes the estimate useless for job costing and unfair to a customer who compares line items.
Assumptions, exclusions, and change orders
Every quote should list what is included and, just as important, what is not. Permits, disposal, scaffolding, temporary power, overtime, and finish selections are common exclusions. State the validity period, the deposit, the payment schedule, and the conditions that trigger a change order.
A change order is a small quote for work outside the original scope, signed before the work starts. The alternative, absorbing extras to avoid confrontation, converts a profitable job into a loss one decision at a time. Track change orders against the original so the final contract value is visible.
Common mistakes
- Applying tax before markup, which understates the tax due.
- Marking up materials only and leaving labor unpriced for overhead.
- Treating markup as margin when setting the price.
- Underestimating hours and absorbing the overrun.
- Quoting a lump sum with no scope, assumptions, or expiry date.
- Discounting to win work without checking the resulting margin.
Practical caveats
Taxability varies by jurisdiction and by job. Some states tax materials but not labor, some tax certain services, and some tax neither. Confirm the rule for the work and the customer’s location, and show tax as a separate line so the treatment is explicit.
Deposits and progress payments protect cash flow. A 30% deposit on the $907.20 quote is $272.16, which funds materials before the work starts. Retainage, common in construction, holds back a percentage until completion; if you accept it, price the delay into the job.
Quotes should expire. A 30-day validity is normal for work exposed to material prices, and longer for stable services. Currency, rounding, and unit assumptions (hours, square feet, linear feet) should be stated so a reader can reproduce the total.
Quote versus actual: job costing
The quote is also the baseline for job costing. Record actual hours and materials against the estimate. If a job quoted at 10 hours takes 12, the labor cost rises from $500 to $600, profit falls from $140 to $40, and the revenue before tax is still $840. The effective labor rate on the work is $70 an hour rather than the $50 rate used.
Review completed jobs monthly. The pattern of overruns, not any single job, tells you whether to raise rates, adjust hours, or change the markup. That feedback loop is what turns quoting from a guess into a priced process.
Frequently asked questions
Should markup come before or after tax?
Before tax. Markup sets the price the customer pays, and tax is calculated on that price. Reversing the order understates the tax due.
How are markup and margin different?
Markup divides profit by cost; margin divides profit by price. A 25% markup is a 20% margin, and a 20% markup on this quote is a 16.7% margin.
Does sales tax apply to labor?
It depends on the jurisdiction and the type of work. Some places tax labor for certain services, others tax materials only. Confirm the rule before quoting a total.
Where should a discount appear on the quote?
On its own line, after markup and before tax, with a reason and an approval. Burying it in a rate hides the price cut from both the customer and your job costing.
How much contingency should I include?
Enough to cover the realistic range of the unknowns in the job, commonly 5% to 15%. State whether unused contingency is refunded or retained.
What if the job takes more hours than quoted?
A fixed quote normally cannot bill the overrun. Track actual hours against the estimate, absorb the variance, and use the pattern to adjust future quotes or move to time-and-materials for uncertain work.
Further reading