Skip to content

Finance

Loan Comparison Calculator

Compare two fixed-rate loans by monthly payment and total interest. Enter the amount, rate, and term for each loan, and the calculator shows both payments, both interest totals, the monthly difference, and which loan costs less overall. It assumes equal monthly payments and rates that never change.

Updated 2026-11-12 Editorial estimate Calccc Editorial Team Free · No sign-up

Loading calculator…

What this calculator does

Two loan offers can look similar and still cost different amounts. A lower rate usually means a lower payment, but a longer term can offset that with extra interest. This calculator runs the standard amortization math on both offers at once so you can see the monthly gap and the total cost side by side. Use it for personal loans, auto loans, or any fixed-rate installment loan you are comparing.

How to use it

  1. Enter loan A's amount, annual rate, and term in years.
  2. Enter loan B's amount, annual rate, and term.
  3. Compare the two monthly payments.
  4. Compare total interest for each loan.
  5. Check the cheaper loan and the monthly difference before you decide.

How it works

Each payment uses M = P x r x (1 + r)^n / ((1 + r)^n - 1). P is the amount borrowed, r is the annual rate divided by 12 and by 100, and n is the number of monthly payments. Total paid is the payment times n, and total interest is total paid minus P. The cheaper loan is the one with lower total interest when both loans cover the same amount and term.

Example calculations

Example 1: $20,000 at 6% vs 5.5% for 5 years

Loan A costs about $386.66 a month with about $3,199 in total interest. Loan B costs about $382.02 with about $2,921 in interest. B is cheaper by about $4.63 a month and about $278 overall.

Example 2: $15,000 at 7% vs 6% for 3 years

Loan A is about $463.16 a month with about $1,674 in interest. Loan B is about $456.33 with about $1,428. B saves about $6.83 a month and about $246 in interest.

Example 3: $30,000 at 5% vs 5.5% for 6 years

Loan A is about $483.15 a month with about $4,787 in interest. Loan B is about $490.14 with about $5,290. A is cheaper by about $6.99 a month and about $503 overall.

What the result means

Total cost is the number that matters most when the loans serve the same purpose. A lower monthly payment can come from a longer term, which may raise total interest even if the rate is lower. Compare the monthly difference for cash-flow fit and the interest difference for cost. Also check the APR, which folds in some fees, and ask about origination fees, prepayment penalties, and variable-rate features. If the two loans differ in amount or term, the comparison is not apples to apples. In that case, compare the total cost of meeting the same need rather than the two payments alone.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing monthly payments without comparing total interest.
  • Comparing loans with different amounts or terms as if they were equal.
  • Using the advertised rate instead of the rate actually offered to you.
  • Ignoring origination fees and other closing costs.
  • Assuming the cheaper loan is available without checking qualification.

Assumptions and limits

  • Both loans have fixed interest rates for the full term.
  • Payments are equal, monthly, and made on time.
  • Both loans are fully paid off at the end of their terms.
  • Fees, insurance, and add-ons are not included.
  • No extra payments or early payoff are applied.

Frequently asked questions

Which loan is cheaper?

When the amount and term are the same, the loan with the lower total interest is cheaper. The calculator labels it for you, but confirm the APR and fees before you apply.

Why can a lower rate still cost more?

A longer term spreads payments over more months. The rate may be lower, but the extra months of interest can add up to a higher total.

Does this include fees?

No. It uses the amount borrowed and the interest rate. Origination fees, closing costs, and add-ons can change which offer is really cheaper.

Can I compare loans with different amounts?

Yes, but interpret the monthly difference carefully. A larger loan naturally has a larger payment, so compare the cost of borrowing the same amount for the same purpose.

What is the difference between rate and APR?

The interest rate sets the payment on the principal. The APR also includes some fees, so it can be a better comparison number across lenders.

Can I use this for a mortgage or auto loan?

Yes, if the loan has a fixed rate and equal monthly payments. For a mortgage, add taxes and insurance separately because they are not part of this calculation.

Sources

This calculator is an educational estimate only and is not financial advice. It does not include all fees or insurance and does not promise approval. Rates and terms vary by lender and borrower. Review each loan agreement and consider speaking with a licensed financial professional.

2026 update

How to use the professional output

This page is not just a formula box. The result is designed to be checked, compared, and taken away.

  • Professional worksheet. The result includes the inputs used, the method and scope, and a one-variable sensitivity check for finance calculators.
  • A/B scenarios. Save two input sets in the browser and compare the primary, secondary, and breakdown figures side by side.
  • Print / PDF and CSV. Print a branded worksheet, or export the year-by-year table when the calculator produces one.
  • Quote differences. The section below explains why a bank, lender, broker, or provider can quote a different number.

The formulas and assumptions above still govern the number. The worksheet makes the estimate auditable; it does not make it a lender quote, tax return, or personalized advice.

Before you use a quote

Why your bank, lender, or provider’s number may differ

A lender’s quote can differ from this estimate because the advertised rate is not always the APR, and fees and credit pricing are lender-specific.

What changes the quote

  • APR versus interest rate. Origination, documentation, and registration fees are part of the APR but not the note rate.
  • Credit and term. A longer term lowers the payment but usually raises total interest.
  • Taxes and insurance. Sales tax, registration, and required coverage vary by state and lender.
  • Promotional pricing. Dealer or issuer incentives may be conditional and can change the effective cost.

How to compare offers

  1. Compare the APR and total cost, not only the monthly payment.
  2. Ask for a written quote or Loan Estimate with all fees itemized.
  3. Use the same loan amount, term, date, and assumptions for every offer.
  4. Check what is excluded: taxes, insurance, closing costs, maintenance, or provider fees.
  5. Keep an emergency reserve; the lowest payment is not always the safest choice.

Reference: CFPB Loan Estimate explainer.

Go deeper

Guides that explain the math

Loan Comparison: APR, Fees, Term, and Total Cost
Finance

Loan Comparison: APR, Fees, Term, and Total Cost

How to compare two loan offers without choosing the lower payment and paying more overall.

6 min read

Calccc Editorial Team · Updated 2026-11-12

Prepared by Calccc Editorial Team as an educational estimate. This page is not a licensed professional review and is not financial, medical, legal, or tax advice.

Editorial estimate prepared by the Calccc Editorial Team; not a licensed professional review.