Key takeaways
- Formulas are estimates.
- Body composition matters.
- Age and health change the target.
- BMI is a population tool.
- Do not chase one number.
The formulas
Devine: men 50 kg + 2.3 kg per inch over 5 ft; women 45.5 kg + 2.3 kg per inch over 5 ft. Robinson, Miller, and Hamwi use different constants. For a 5 ft 10 in man, Devine gives about 73 kg (161 lb); Robinson about 70 kg (154 lb). The spread is normal.
BMI
BMI = weight (kg) ÷ height (m)². A BMI of 18.5–24.9 is often called normal, 25–29.9 overweight, and 30+ obesity. BMI does not distinguish muscle from fat, and it can misclassify athletes and older adults. Use it with waist circumference and clinical assessment.
Body composition
Two people at the same height and weight can have very different body fat and muscle. A muscular athlete may have a high BMI but low body fat. An older adult may have a normal BMI but low muscle mass. The scale alone is incomplete.
An example
A 5 ft 6 in woman: Devine 45.5 + 2.3 × 6 = 59.3 kg (131 lb); Robinson 49 kg + 1.7 × 6 = 59.2 kg; Miller 53.1 + 1.36 × 6 = 61.3 kg. The formulas cluster around 130–135 lb but differ by several pounds.
What to compare
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist circumference, body composition, and health markers. A single ideal weight is less useful than a healthy range and a stable trend.
Formula comparison
For a 5 ft 9 in man: Devine 50 + 2.3 × 9 = 70.7 kg (156 lb); Robinson 52 + 1.9 × 9 = 69.1 kg (152 lb); Miller 56.2 + 1.41 × 9 = 68.9 kg (152 lb); Hamwi 48 + 2.7 × 9 = 72.3 kg (159 lb). The range is 152–159 lb. A single target is false precision.
Waist and health
Waist circumference and waist-to-height ratio can add information that BMI misses. A higher waist with a normal BMI may indicate visceral fat. Blood pressure, glucose, and lipids are also part of the picture. Use the calculator with clinical measures.
What to compare
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers.
What the formulas do not know
They do not know muscle mass, bone density, age, pregnancy, or health conditions. A bodybuilder may be classified as overweight by BMI. An older adult may have a normal BMI but low muscle. Use the formulas as a range and a starting point.
What to compare
Compare the range, body composition, waist, and health markers. A single target is not a diagnosis.
What to compare
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single ideal weight is false precision.
Use the range as a conversation starter with a clinician.
Health-first approach
Focus on strength, sleep, nutrition, and activity rather than one weight. A clinician can help set a realistic range and monitor health markers. A number on a formula is not a diagnosis.
What to compare
Compare the range, body composition, and health markers.
What to compare
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single ideal weight is false precision.
Use the range with a clinician.
Final check
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis.
Use the range with a clinician.
Final check
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis; use the range as a starting point with a clinician.
Final check
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis; use the range as a starting point with a clinician.
Focus on health and habits.
Final check
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis; use the range as a starting point with a clinician.
Focus on health and habits over a single number.
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis; use the range with a clinician.
Focus on health and habits.
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis; use the range as a starting point with a clinician.
Focus on health and habits over a single number.
Compare the formula range, BMI, waist, body composition, and health markers. A single weight is not a diagnosis; use the range as a starting point with a clinician, and focus on health and habits over one number.
Now compare the range, body composition, and health markers, and use the result as a conversation starter rather than a target.
Now compare the range, body composition, and health markers, and use the result as a conversation starter with a clinician.
Now compare the range, body composition, and health markers, and use the result as a conversation starter with a clinician rather than a target.
Now check the range and the health markers.
Compare the formula range with the health markers and use it as a conversation starter, not a fixed target.
Frequently asked questions
What is my ideal weight?
There is no single number. Formulas give a range; body composition and health matter.
Is BMI reliable?
It is a population screening tool, not a diagnosis. It can misclassify athletes and older adults.
Which formula is best?
They are all estimates. Use the range, not one formula.
Should I try to hit the number?
Focus on health, strength, and habits. A clinician can help set a realistic target.
Further reading
Keep exploring
Decision path